Settling an estate is often emotional, stressful, and overwhelming. Families are frequently forced to make major decisions while grieving, dealing with probate, cleaning out homes, coordinating with relatives, and trying to determine what personal property is actually worth.
After conducting estate auctions and liquidations for more than 25 years, we have seen families make the same costly mistakes over and over again — often with the best intentions.
Here are some of the most common estate liquidation mistakes we encounter, along with how to avoid them.
#1. The Vultures Are Swarming! Be Alert!
The unfortunate reality is that when someone passes away, the vultures often come out. Even worse, those vultures are sometimes trusted friends or even close relatives.
We have seen it hundreds of times — siblings, nieces, nephews, sons, daughters, neighbors, and acquaintances suddenly appear with stories about why certain valuables supposedly belong to them. Entire collections of firearms, sports memorabilia, jewelry, coins, cash, and family heirlooms have vanished almost immediately after a loved one’s passing.
Then come the familiar phone calls:
“Uncle Jesse borrowed my Remington 870 shotgun years ago, and I’d like it back.”
Of course, this is often news to everyone else involved.
Several years ago, we were handling an estate in Saginaw, Michigan. While preparing items for transport to our auction facility, we discovered a remarkable collection of artifacts recovered from the old Atocha shipwreck.
The executor said to me:
“I don’t think we can sell those because one of his old friends says they belong to him.”
I asked whether there was any documentation, receipt, or proof supporting the claim.
There was none.
After a brief discussion, the items were put up for auction, and the “old friend” never said another word about it.
Unfortunately, situations like this are far more common than most families realize.
#2. Protect and Preserve the Estate
In Michigan, the probate court must appoint a Personal Representative for the estate. However, between death and the official court appointment, there is often a transitional period during which important responsibilities still require immediate attention.
During that period, someone must step forward to protect and preserve the estate.
That means securing the home, garages, and outbuildings by changing locks and installing cameras or monitoring systems to help prevent theft and vandalism. Pets must be cared for, utilities monitored, and important operational systems such as furnaces, plumbing, and sump pumps checked regularly.
What should not happen is people casually walking through the property, helping themselves to belongings, or prematurely distributing assets.
The role during this transitional period is to preserve the estate — not divide it.
We strongly recommend photographing and documenting every room, closet, safe, collection, vehicle, firearm, and valuable item. Record serial numbers, especially on firearms, coins, jewelry, and collectibles. Good documentation protects both the estate and the person responsible for overseeing it.
BONUS TIP:
Contact your local police department and inform them that the homeowner has passed away and the property is temporarily vacant. Many departments will conduct occasional drive-bys to monitor for suspicious activity.
#3. Who’s the Boss? — Who Actually Has Legal Authority?
One of the most common estate mistakes families make is assuming everyone has equal authority immediately after a death.
In reality, legal authority is often far more limited than many people realize.
One of the biggest problems occurs during the first few days after a passing, especially when multiple people have keys to the property. Simply possessing a key does not automatically grant legal authority to enter the home, remove valuables, or distribute personal property.
While surviving spouses or lawful occupants may continue accessing the residence, authority over estate assets generally rests with the individual formally appointed by the probate court as the Personal Representative.
Until probate proceedings are underway, legal authority may remain unclear. This is why families should proceed carefully and avoid making assumptions about who has the right to take, sell, or distribute estate property.
#4. Retain Legal Representation
Despite all the information available online, there is still no substitute for competent probate counsel.
Over the years, we have watched many individuals attempt to navigate estate administration entirely on their own — and unfortunately, critical mistakes are common.
Several years ago, a woman hired us to sell her late father’s sports memorabilia collection. She assured us she had the legal authority to do so, and the auction was extremely successful.
Two years later, her estranged brother contacted us and said that she never had legal authority to sell the assets. Attorneys became involved, lawsuits followed, and the matter turned into an expensive legal battle.
I do not know how the case ultimately ended, but I do know she spent thousands of dollars defending herself.
Do it right the first time and avoid unnecessary legal problems later.
#5. Everyone is an Internet Appraiser
Of all the mistakes families make, this may be one of the biggest.
Research is important. Google, eBay, and online marketplaces can provide valuable information. However, many families become excited after seeing high asking prices online, only to discover those examples do not reflect actual market demand.
I am sure many readers are familiar with PBS’s Antiques Roadshow. Personally, I enjoy the program because it showcases highly respected professional appraisers and remarkable museum-quality objects.
The problem is that many viewers become convinced they own the exact same item they saw featured on television.
After decades in this business, I can confidently say that nearly every “same exact item” we are shown turns out to be something entirely different — reproductions, later examples, mass-produced department store merchandise, or similar-looking pieces of far lower quality.
I once received a call from a woman asking about the value of an antique butter churn. She sent photographs, and I complimented her on its excellent condition and original stenciling. I estimated the value at approximately $250.
Immediately, she became upset.
“You don’t know your antiques! I saw the same one on eBay for $800!”
While she was talking, I located the listing she referenced.
The problem?
It had not sold. In fact, it had been sitting unsold on eBay for over 374 days.
One of the biggest misconceptions online is confusing asking prices with actual market value.
Value is not determined by what someone hopes to get.
Value is determined by what qualified buyers are actually willing to pay.
#6. Put the Dumpster on Hold
I could write an entire book filled with stories about valuable items that accidentally ended up in dumpsters.
We understand how overwhelming estate clean-outs can become. Families are emotional, exhausted, busy with their own lives, and often under pressure to clean out a property quickly.
Unfortunately, that urgency can lead to devastating mistakes.
We have seen antique advertising signs, military items, rare paperwork, collectible toys, historical documents, vintage photographs, jewelry, firearms, and valuable heirlooms thrown away simply because nobody realized what they were.
Before you start filling dumpsters, slow down and seek guidance from someone experienced in estate liquidation or appraisal work.
Once something goes into the trash, it is usually gone forever.
#7. Don’t Self-Destruct With Self-Storage Units
One of the most expensive mistakes families make is moving an entire household into storage “temporarily” without any long-term plan.
We understand why it happens. Emotions are high, the real estate may need to be sold quickly, and sometimes it simply feels easier to deal with the belongings later.
The problem is that storage units often become “out of sight, out of mind.”
Meanwhile, the monthly payments continue — sometimes for years.
We routinely encounter storage units filled with common furniture, outdated household items, mattresses, damaged boxes, and sentimental belongings nobody ever comes back to claim. In many cases, the contents deteriorate due to moisture, mold, insects, or rodent damage.
Not long ago, we cleaned out four storage units for a gentleman who had maintained them for more than 12 years. He had spent over $46,000 in storage fees.
The saleable contents brought less than $8,000.
Storage can make sense in certain situations, but only if there is a clear and temporary plan in place.
Remember: storage delays decisions. It rarely solves them.
#8. Don’t Confuse Emotional Value With Market Value
One of the most difficult aspects of settling an estate is separating emotional attachment from true market value.
After the loss of a loved one, ordinary household items can suddenly carry tremendous sentimental weight because they remind us of a person, memory, or moment in time. There is absolutely nothing wrong with that. Some possessions become priceless to surviving family members for emotional reasons alone.
However, emotional value and market value are often very different things.
Over the years, we have seen families become shocked or offended when treasured items carried little monetary value in the open marketplace. At the same time, we have also seen families nearly throw away items they considered insignificant, only to discover they were highly desirable to collectors.
The market does not determine what something means to your family.
The market only determines what another buyer is willing to pay.
A scratched kitchen table where a family shared decades of holiday dinners may carry enormous sentimental value but little resale value. Meanwhile, an old advertising sign collecting dust in the garage may bring thousands of dollars at auction despite carrying little emotional attachment.
We have also witnessed situations where multiple family members become emotionally attached to the estate’s most valuable items, which can quickly create tension and conflict.
This is why it is important to approach estate decisions with both your heart and your head.
#9. Don’t Rush the Process
This advice is often easier said than done.
Serving as the Personal Representative of an estate can completely disrupt your life — especially when you are balancing employment, family responsibilities, grief, and probate matters all at once.
Grief clouds judgment, even when we believe we are thinking clearly.
I know this not only from professional experience, but from personal experience after losing my brother.
Even though estate liquidation and evaluation is my profession, I convinced myself that I could manage my grief while simultaneously handling major estate decisions. Looking back, I realized I could have handled several things much better had I simply slowed down.
Much of the pressure came from planning his funeral within 24 hours of his passing while simultaneously trying to address family matters and estate responsibilities.
In the end, everything worked out.
However, the experience taught me an important lesson:
Just because decisions can be made quickly does not mean they should be.
Sometimes the best decision is simply giving yourself time to think clearly.
#10. Consult With a Certified Auctioneer and Appraiser
Notice I said consult with — not necessarily hire — a certified auctioneer or appraiser.
If you are serving as the Personal Representative of an estate, the more information you gather, the better decisions you will ultimately make.
A simple consultation can provide valuable guidance regarding what may have value, what should be preserved, what should not be discarded, and what options may exist for properly handling estate assets.
Just as importantly, experienced auctioneers and appraisers bring a neutral perspective. We have no emotional attachment to the property, which allows us to evaluate situations objectively.
And if you are dealing with difficult family dynamics — and most families have at least one difficult personality involved — professional guidance becomes even more important.
Good documentation, outside expertise, and objective opinions can help reduce conflict, protect the estate, and protect you.
Settling an estate can feel overwhelming, especially while grieving the loss of someone you love. When you are ready, please feel free to contact American Eagle Auction & Appraisal Company for a free, no-pressure conversation. We genuinely care about helping families navigate these difficult situations with honesty, professionalism, and compassion.
If we can help in any way, call us at (734) 223-3277.
